Club Tobacco Reviews

Member ratings from Miami Pipe Club tobacco tastings.

Club averages are calculated from member review forms. Individual reviews may include comments when provided.

Submit A Review
Order By Blend A-Z Most Reviews Top Rated Most Recent
Packaging: Tin Latest Review: May 4, 2026

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 5.00
Moisture Level 5.00
Ease of Lighting 5.00
Strength / Intensity 3.00
Smoothness 3.00
Flavor Depth 2.00
Flavor Complexity 2.00
Overall Flavor 3.00
Scent Match 3.00
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.00
Maintains Flavor 2.00
Room Note 2.00
Jed K. 3.17 / 5 · May 4, 2026

Very pleasant tin note and mildly pleasant smoke. Too bad the two don't match better.

Packaging: Bulk Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Jul 7, 2026

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 4.00
Moisture Level 2.50
Ease of Lighting 3.50
Strength / Intensity 2.75
Smoothness 3.00
Flavor Depth 2.25
Flavor Complexity 2.50
Overall Flavor 2.50
Scent Match 2.75
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.25
Maintains Flavor 3.25
Room Note 3.50
Gus Z. 2.58 / 5 · Jul 7, 2026
Mike N. 2.58 / 5 · Jul 7, 2026
George G. 3.42 / 5 · Jul 6, 2026
Ben C. 3.33 / 5 · Jul 6, 2026

Not as sweet tasting as it smells out of the jar..

Packaging: Bulk Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Jul 7, 2026

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 3.83
Moisture Level 3.57
Ease of Lighting 3.71
Strength / Intensity 2.71
Smoothness 3.57
Flavor Depth 2.71
Flavor Complexity 2.43
Overall Flavor 3.29
Scent Match 3.67
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.71
Maintains Flavor 3.29
Room Note 3.57
Nick P. 2.58 / 5 · Jul 7, 2026
George G. 3.75 / 5 · Jul 7, 2026

Better than the cherry vanilla

Ben C. 3.58 / 5 · Jul 7, 2026
Jeffery N. 3.50 / 5 · Jul 7, 2026

This is a light aromatic. The vanilla is the dominant scent in the tin note, and the main flavor at the top of the bowl. After the first third the vanilla goes away and a light nutty caramel flavor persists down to the bottom of the bowl.

Mike N. 3.00 / 5 · Jul 7, 2026
Gus Z. 3.10 / 5 · Jul 6, 2026
Rohan R. 3.75 / 5 · Jul 6, 2026
Packaging: Bulk Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Oct 6, 2023

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 4.00
Moisture Level 4.00
Ease of Lighting 4.00
Strength / Intensity 3.00
Smoothness 4.00
Flavor Depth 2.00
Flavor Complexity 1.00
Overall Flavor 2.00
Scent Match 2.00
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.00
Maintains Flavor 3.00
Room Note 2.00
Ben C. 2.83 / 5 · Oct 6, 2023
Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: English Latest Review: Jan 5, 2026

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 3.75
Moisture Level 4.00
Ease of Lighting 4.25
Strength / Intensity 4.00
Smoothness 3.25
Flavor Depth 3.75
Flavor Complexity 3.50
Overall Flavor 3.50
Scent Match 3.50
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.25
Maintains Flavor 4.00
Room Note 3.00
Jed K. 2.42 / 5 · Jan 5, 2026

I was told it smokes like a wet dog. I agree, but better than a skunk.

James U. 4.50 / 5 · Jan 5, 2026
Rohan R. 4.00 / 5 · Jan 5, 2026
Mike W. 3.67 / 5 · Jan 5, 2026

Heavy Perique. Nice VaPer overall.

Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Feb 5, 2024

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 2.00
Moisture Level 3.00
Ease of Lighting 5.00
Strength / Intensity 5.00
Smoothness 4.00
Flavor Depth 3.00
Flavor Complexity 3.00
Overall Flavor 3.00
Scent Match 4.00
Pleasantness of Smoke 4.00
Maintains Flavor 4.00
Room Note 3.00
Ben C. 3.58 / 5 · Feb 5, 2024
Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Apr 7, 2025

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 3.25
Moisture Level 3.00
Ease of Lighting 2.00
Strength / Intensity 2.75
Smoothness 3.00
Flavor Depth 2.25
Flavor Complexity 2.25
Overall Flavor 2.50
Scent Match 2.00
Pleasantness of Smoke 2.75
Maintains Flavor 3.50
Room Note 3.00
Ben C. 3.25 / 5 · Apr 7, 2025
Unsigned 2.50 / 5 · Apr 7, 2025
Francisco P. 3.17 / 5 · Apr 7, 2025
Jed K. 1.83 / 5 · Apr 7, 2025

Flowering tin + meh smoke

Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: English Latest Review: Jun 1, 2026

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 3.67
Moisture Level 3.67
Ease of Lighting 4.00
Strength / Intensity 3.00
Smoothness 3.33
Flavor Depth 3.33
Flavor Complexity 3.00
Overall Flavor 2.67
Scent Match 2.33
Pleasantness of Smoke 2.67
Maintains Flavor 4.00
Room Note 3.00
Mike N. 3.58 / 5 · Jun 1, 2026
Nick P. 3.08 / 5 · Jun 1, 2026
Ben C. 2.91 / 5 · Jun 1, 2026
Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Aug 5, 2024

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 4.00
Moisture Level 3.50
Ease of Lighting 2.50
Strength / Intensity 3.50
Smoothness 4.00
Flavor Depth 3.00
Flavor Complexity 3.00
Overall Flavor 3.00
Scent Match 3.00
Pleasantness of Smoke 4.00
Maintains Flavor 2.50
Room Note 3.00
Mike N. 4.08 / 5 · Aug 5, 2024
Ben C. 2.42 / 5 · Aug 5, 2024
Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Oct 2, 2023

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 4.00
Moisture Level 3.67
Ease of Lighting 3.33
Strength / Intensity 3.67
Smoothness 3.33
Flavor Depth 3.33
Flavor Complexity 3.00
Overall Flavor 3.67
Scent Match 3.67
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.33
Maintains Flavor 3.67
Room Note 3.00
Mike N. 3.75 / 5 · Oct 2, 2023
Andres O. 2.75 / 5 · Oct 2, 2023

It's good.

Ben C. 3.92 / 5 · Oct 2, 2023
Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Apr 6, 2026

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 2.00
Moisture Level 1.00
Ease of Lighting 1.00
Strength / Intensity 5.00
Smoothness 3.00
Flavor Depth 3.00
Flavor Complexity 2.00
Overall Flavor 2.00
Scent Match 5.00
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.00
Maintains Flavor 3.00
Room Note 3.00
Rohan R. 2.75 / 5 · Apr 6, 2026
Packaging: Tin Majority Blend Type: Aromatic Latest Review: Aug 4, 2025

Category Averages

Tin/Jar Aroma 4.25
Moisture Level 4.25
Ease of Lighting 4.25
Strength / Intensity 3.25
Smoothness 3.50
Flavor Depth 2.00
Flavor Complexity 2.00
Overall Flavor 3.00
Scent Match 3.25
Pleasantness of Smoke 3.00
Maintains Flavor 2.75
Room Note 3.50
Unsigned 3.83 / 5 · Aug 4, 2025

The Virginias take center stage & the starfruit was scent in the tin & subtle in the smoke

Ben C. 3.33 / 5 · Aug 4, 2025
Nick P. 3.17 / 5 · Aug 4, 2025
Mike N. 2.67 / 5 · Aug 4, 2025